By Eitan Levi
As Yashar leader Gadi Eisenkot steps into the 28 day window granted by President Isaac Herzog to piece together a governing coalition, Israel finds itself navigating a tense and uncertain juncture, one where constitutional rules and real world security concerns blur together. Eisenkot comes in with the backing of 67 Knesset members, a comfortable lead over Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu’s 46. But here’s the thing: Netanyahu still calls the shots. He retains executive power, controls the defense apparatus, and shapes national security policy while the standoff with Iran edges closer to a breaking point. Right now, the country’s biggest question, maybe the only one that really matters, is whether a caretaker prime minister actually has the authority or moral standing to launch a massive strike on Tehran.
The legal backdrop here is rooted in Israel’s Basic Law: The Government, especially Sections 40 and 30. The law makes it clear: until a new cabinet is sworn in, the outgoing administration keeps working. There’s no real legal split between the powers of a “normal” and a “caretaker” government when it comes to making war or launching big military operations. Still, Israel’s Supreme Court has spent decades building a doctrine of caution. When a government isn’t backed by a current parliamentary majority and is just keeping the lights on, its decisions have to pass extra tough tests: reasonableness, proportionality, and necessity. If there’s an immediate threat, a caretaker’s hands aren’t completely tied, but major, irreversible decisions that can wait for the next government really demand a higher stamp of democratic approval.
History offers a few guideposts, but they only go so far. Think back: In December 2008, while on his way out, Prime Minister Ehud Olmert kicked off Operation Cast Lead after a barrage of rockets hit southern Israel. Then in May 2021, Netanyahu himself, as a caretaker, led Operation Guardian of the Walls as rockets rained down on Jerusalem. August 2022 saw another example: caretaker PM Yair Lapid and Defense Minister Benny Gantz launched Operation Breaking Dawn, targeting Palestinian Islamic Jihad, after Attorney General Gali Baharav Miara okayed the move, seeing little risk of a wider war. In each case, these were responses to clear, immediate aggression or carefully limited strikes, mostly in Gaza, not sweeping offensives with long term implications.

The idea of a full blown campaign against Iran, especially one aimed at toppling its regime, is a different beast altogether. Such an operation isn’t just risky, it would almost certainly ignite a multi front regional war. That kind of decision can’t be made lightly. It needs official debate and a green light from the full government or Israel’s Ministerial Committee on National Security Affairs, as spelled out in Section 40(a) of the Basic Law. Yet, here’s the twist: Israel’s security cabinet hasn’t met since October 5, before the last election, even though defense forces have been on high alert waiting for a meeting set for November 15.
This legal and constitutional tug of war isn’t happening behind closed doors. Eisenkot just fired off a formal warning to Netanyahu, urging him to hold off on any major military action that isn’t absolutely urgent until a new government is in place. He warned that striking now, without an unavoidable threat, could damage Israel’s democratic foundations and put the country’s top military personnel in a nearly impossible legal situation. At the same time, Eisenkot asked Attorney General Baharav Miara to lay out exactly what a caretaker government can and cannot do, and to make sure he gets regular intelligence updates due to his new presidential mandate. Netanyahu’s office fired back, insisting that all moves are in total coordination with military and security leaders, accusing Eisenkot of dragging national security into politics, and repeating the call for a broad unity government.
Piling onto this internal tension is a sharp strategic split between Jerusalem and Washington. After the recent U.S. midterms, President Donald Trump (in office at the time) told media and visitors, including Qatari Prime Minister Mohammed bin Abdulrahman Al Thani, that the U.S. sees no need to step up military action against Iran right now. Secretary of State Marco Rubio and Vice President JD Vance have doubled down on sanctions and naval blockades, and the administration is working diplomatic angles through Doha and other regional players to see if a deal is possible. Trump even said at Arlington National Cemetery that the U.S. wants total victory and keeps the military option open, but, at the moment, Washington’s approach is all about pressure and diplomacy, not airstrikes.
Netanyahu doesn’t see it that way. Addressing the 26th Knesset, he argued that only toppled ayatollahs can truly end the nuclear and regional threat from Iran. If Israel goes it alone and launches a unilateral offensive while Washington is betting on diplomacy, it risks a major rift with its most important ally, and that’s at a time when U.S. congressional support for Israel is shifting in real time.
This isn’t just a matter of what the law technically allows under Section 40. It’s about what responsible leadership actually looks like. A caretaker prime minister owes it to Israelis to act, quickly and decisively, if danger is looming overhead. But launching a bold, regime changing war without fresh democratic backing, full cabinet debate, or alignment with Washington would stretch Israel’s constitutional fabric to the breaking point. Right now, holding onto public trust and staying in sync with key allies is just as crucial for security as any show of military strength. In these moments of transition, how leaders handle the gray areas can define the nation’s future as much as any missile or maneuver.
About the Author
Eitan Levi is a Security and Geopolitical Analyst with expertise in Israeli defence strategy, Iran’s regional operations, Middle Eastern power rivalries, and Israel’s security partnerships.