By Eitan Levi
As Israel navigates the fragile aftermath of its November 2026 elections, with Yashar leader Gadi Eisenkot holding the presidential mandate to form a governing coalition, the nation’s political discourse remains myopically fixated on familiar internal battles. Coalition arithmetic, portfolio allocations, military deployments across Gaza and Lebanon, and the eternal friction over ultra Orthodox enlistment dominate the nightly news. Yet, as political scholar Yedidia Stern warned in a sobering intervention published in The Jerusalem Post, our political leadership is dangerously blind to the ultimate existential threat looming on the horizon. The greatest peril facing Israel today is not military, but diplomatic. Within a remarkably short window, the steady erosion of international legitimacy, particularly in the United States, threatens to transform from a chronic headache into an acute catastrophe.
The statistics detailing this diplomatic hemorrhaging are no longer abstract projections; they are a blinking red warning light. According to a CNN survey released earlier this year, public support for Israel among American adults has plummeted to 50 percent, representing a steep historical decline from previous decades. The generational divide is even more alarming. Among Americans under thirty, favorable views of Israel have dwindled into the low thirties, while young Democrats increasingly view the bilateral relationship through an adversarial lens. As Stern emphasized, Israelis must wake up to the non negligible probability that within two years, a hostile presidential administration could occupy the White House. The consequences of such a shift would not be theoretical. They could manifest swiftly in devastating forms: a formal American arms embargo, restrictions on intelligence sharing, or exclusion from key international financial and banking systems. A nation entirely dependent on strategic deterrence and external supply lines cannot survive complete international isolation.
For decades, Israeli politics has operated under the cynical maxim attributed to former US secretary of state Henry Kissinger, who famously remarked that Israel has no foreign policy, only domestic politics. The upcoming government, whatever its final shape, must execute a total reversal of that formula. Every domestic decision, from settlement regulation in the West Bank to legislative proposals in the Knesset, must be weighed against its immediate resonance in Washington, London, Berlin, and Brussels. Israelis live naturally in the realm of the immediate, trapped inside a perpetual cycle of security crises that have consumed the national psyche since the trauma of October 7, 2023. That black curtain of perpetual conflict has fostered a dangerous illusion that raw military force alone can solve every regional challenge, blinding leaders to the reality that tactical battlefield victories mean little if strategic legitimacy is entirely forfeited.

To reverse this downward spiral, Israel’s next prime minister must prioritize international standing above narrow partisan survival. That strategic imperative begins with the architectural design of the coalition currently being assembled. A government that incorporates the extreme Right, whether as dominant partners or even as minority voices in a unity framework, is dead on arrival in Western capitals. The presence of far right figures who openly advocate for annexation, reject international law, or dismiss Palestinian civil rights makes it impossible to convince skeptical allies of Israel’s peaceful intentions.
Simultaneously, Israel must confront the mounting lawlessness in the West Bank. Reasserting state authority over unauthorized outposts and halting extremist violence against Palestinian civilians is not a concession to foreign pressure; it is a vital act of self preservation. Allowing radical fringe elements to dictate national security and legal norms in Judea and Samaria provides ammunition to international tribunals and accelerates the legal isolation of the state. Furthermore, Israel must transition away from the open ended pursuit of total military victory toward reasonable diplomatic arrangements that stabilize its borders and restore predictability to the region.
Domestically, incorporating unexpected political actors can serve as a powerful counter narrative against hostile propaganda. As Stern argued, bringing Mansour Abbas and the Ra’am party into the governing coalition would instantly shatter the malicious lie propagated by Israel’s detractors that the Jewish state is an apartheid regime. Demonstrating that Arab citizens are full, active participants in executive governance projects a vibrant, pluralistic democracy capable of managing its internal diversity. Conversely, keeping the political structure locked in rigid ethnic enclaves only feeds international isolation.
At the same time, the inclusion of Likud in a broad unity government should remain an open possibility, provided the price is right. However, the leadership of that government must transition away from Benjamin Netanyahu. After nearly two decades at the helm, Netanyahu’s name is inextricably linked in Western capitals with the collapse of Israel’s diplomatic standing and the fracturing of bipartisan support in Washington. Giving someone else the mandate to lead is not an ideological surrender; it is a necessary tactical reset to restore credibility with our closest allies.
The clock is ticking down rapidly. Israel has a narrow window of roughly two years to rebuild its legitimacy, repair bipartisan bridges in the United States, and reconnect with the moderate middle of Western public opinion. Global antisemitism and the hollowing out of the liberal political center are powerful external headwinds that Israel cannot control. But much of the damage remains within our power to fix. If our leaders continue to sacrifice foreign policy on the altar of domestic political survival, they will inherit a nation that won its wars on the battlefield only to find itself utterly alone and defenseless before the judgment of the world.
About the Author
Eitan Levi is a Security and Geopolitical Analyst with expertise in Israeli defence strategy, Iran’s regional operations, Middle Eastern power rivalries, and Israel’s security partnerships.