By Noam Shalev
People keep arguing about who really has sovereignty in Judea and Samaria, the West Bank, tossing out legal claims, history, and predictions about who will live there in the future. But the real, pressing question isn’t wrapped up in abstract dreams of borders. It’s about whether Israel is actually enforcing basic law and order in these areas.
Take Efrat, for example. When Mayor Dovi Shefler recently said supporting Jewish sovereignty is needed to rein in settler violence, he flipped the issue upside down. It’s not just about sovereignty; it’s about accountability. If the law isn’t enforced, if authorities let vigilante extremism go unchecked, talk about expanded sovereignty starts to feel hollow, even damaging to Israel’s own democratic roots.
What’s happening in Efrat and around Gush Etzion puts this contradiction on full display. Residents who want Jewish settlement to thrive in the long run have been pleading with Mayor Shefler to confront real problems: intimidation, destroyed property, even outright violence coming from places like Eitam Farm and Kochav Yehuda. The targets? Palestinian neighbors in places like Khirbet Al Nahla, communities that coexisted peacefully with Efrat for years. There are mental health professionals, locals, all documenting the toxic climate of fear and intimidation. And if municipal leaders stay silent, the moral cost just keeps growing heavier.
Behind closed doors, leaders aren’t pretending the violence doesn’t exist. They just look at it through a lens of “usefulness.” They see these settlers and their supporters as tools, a way to secure land, stop unauthorized farming, and stake claims that might help Efrat expand someday. If leaders decide that the benefits of intimidation outweigh the basic need for lawfulness, their priorities are seriously off track. Ignoring lawbreaking just to gain an edge in territorial disputes isn’t nation building; it’s tearing away at the principle that law matters for everyone.
This kind of compromise isn’t just a local problem; it’s happening across the country. For years, politicians have insisted that law enforcement agencies can’t do much about extremists in the West Bank. Honestly, there’s no shortage of capability. The IDF and the Israel Police have all the authority and muscle they need. What’s missing? Political will. When government officials look the other way or even defend lawbreakers just because their actions fit certain ideological aims, they’re abandoning the basic duty every sovereign has.

It’s common for settlement leaders to cheer these “facts on the ground,” seeing them as strategic wins. But let’s be real: celebrating lawlessness is a dangerous game. If Israel claims sovereignty here, then it’s responsible for everyone living within its borders. That includes enforcing criminal law fairly and keeping a tight grip on who gets to use force. If Israel’s leadership chooses to look away when the law’s broken, they lose the moral legitimacy to govern. Sovereignty stripped of responsibility becomes just a tool for special privilege, not a universal protector of rights.
This failure stretches way beyond West Bank tensions. It feeds international criticism, pushes Israel into diplomatic corners, and costs them bipartisan support in Washington. When allies see a system where accountability is slipping, defending Israel’s actions becomes a lot tougher. Internal security and global standing aren’t separate, they move together. So, every time the state tolerates radical elements who disregard the law, it chips away at Israel’s ability to stand strong against real dangers, like Iran and its network of threats.
If Israel wants to fix this, it’s time for honest reflection from the mainstream pro settlement crowd. You can’t defend the Zionist vision or secure Jewish communities in the West Bank by letting extremism and criminal behavior slide. Local leaders like Shefler and national policymakers need to face the reality: fighting for sovereignty means carrying the burden of fair, tough law enforcement. If Israeli authorities won’t protect vulnerable neighbors or go after offenders in their own towns, talk about sovereignty will never feel real. The foundation for the settlement project has to be internal accountability. Until the law is enforced equally for everyone, regardless of which side they’re on, the moral basis for Israel’s claims in the West Bank stays shaky.
About the Author
Noam Shalev is a Political Affairs Commentator covering Israeli government policy, US-Israel relations, coalition politics, and diplomatic engagement across the Middle East.